Fraud Bugs cockroach badge Fraud Bugsfraudbugs.com · Independent evidence desk

Profile · Option One Mortgage / Sand Canyon

The subprime machine that became a shell.

Option One Mortgage Corporation was H&R Block's subprime lending arm, based in Irvine, California. In the last three years of the housing boom it originated tens of billions of dollars of high-interest loans. Then it collapsed, sold its servicing, and renamed its empty shell Sand Canyon Corporation — the name that kept answering lawsuits for years afterward.

$64.7Bhigh-interest loans originated 2005–07
32,400loans originated in Massachusetts alone, 2004–07
$125MMassachusetts AG settlement package, 2011
$28.2MSEC settlement, 2012

The record

Sued by a state, charged by the SEC, named in the leading case

Option One is the rare company that appears in the foreclosure-crisis record from every direction: as a lender accused of making loans designed to fail, as an issuer accused of misleading its own investors, and as a link in the broken assignment chain of Ibanez.

Massachusetts Attorney GeneralAug 9, 2011

$125 million: “loans that it knew were likely to fail”

Attorney General Martha Coakley's office sued Option One in 2008 over roughly 32,400 Massachusetts loans originated between 2004 and 2007. The settlement, filed in Suffolk Superior Court against Sand Canyon — “formerly known as Option One Mortgage Corporation” — was valued at $125 million: $9.8 million paid to the Commonwealth, plus an aggressive loan-modification program for about 5,500 Massachusetts loans, run by servicer American Home Mortgage Servicing Inc., estimated at $115 million in relief. The AG's statement of the case: “Option One made loans that it knew were likely to fail and it discriminated against African-American and Latino borrowers,” alleging risk-layered loans with an excessive risk of default and broker pricing discretion that charged minority borrowers more.

Read the settlement coverage ↗
SEC enforcementApr 24, 2012

$28.2 million for misleading its own investors

The Securities and Exchange Commission charged Option One with misleading investors in more than $4 billion of subprime residential mortgage-backed securities offerings in early 2007 — promising it would repurchase or replace mortgages that breached its representations and warranties, while failing to disclose that its financial condition was significantly deteriorating and would inhibit its ability to do exactly that. Option One, by then known as Sand Canyon Corporation, paid $28.2 million — $14.25 million disgorgement, $3.98 million prejudgment interest, and a $10 million penalty — without admitting or denying the allegations.

Read the SEC's case summary ↗
Massachusetts Supreme Judicial CourtJan 7, 2011

The blank assignments in Ibanez

The defining standing case of the crisis ran through Option One's paperwork. In U.S. Bank National Association v. Ibanez, the mortgage at issue reached Option One on an assignment executed in blank — no assignee named — and left the same way, on its way to the securitization trust whose trustee later foreclosed. The Supreme Judicial Court held that assignments in blank “convey nothing and are void,” and voided the foreclosures. Option One's role in the chain is a matter of the court's own record. See the U.S. Bank profile for the full case.

Read the Ibanez opinion ↗
H&R Block SEC filings2007 – 2008

The wind-down: shut, sold, renamed

Per H&R Block's own SEC correspondence: Sand Canyon Corporation, formerly Option One Mortgage Corporation, ceased originating mortgage loans in December 2007, and its remaining servicing operations were sold in April 2008 — effective April 30, 2008 — to American Home Mortgage Servicing, which remained the servicer for the majority of the loans Option One had originated. The origination machine was gone; what remained was the renamed shell and its legal tail, which is why later court papers so often name “Sand Canyon fka Option One.” A company can stop lending and still spend a decade in the record.

Read the H&R Block SEC filing ↗

Did Option One do it to you too? Tell your story — submissions are stories to research, not findings.

Fairness policy

Corrections & company responses

Evidence can change the record.

If you are the subject of a published complaint, you may request a correction or submit a response. Identify the source card and provide a precise factual correction with supporting public documentation. The same email workflow below is used so the site does not falsely imply server-side submission.

Email a correction or response